Make bulleted lists act correctly when it's moved by text wrap
The bullets on the image attached have a left indent of 3 mm and a first line left indent -3 mm, but have incorrect layout, because the adjacent text box has text wrap applied, which displaces the text with bullets.
Anonymous
shared this idea
Information: We attempted a fix for these issues in ID 2020. But later we found that the fix has caused some new issues due to which this fix was reverted in ID 2021.
As a result of which, the behaviour of ID 2021 is not consistent with ID 2020. The behaviour of ID 2021 in this case is expected to match with ID 2019.
Hope this helps!
17 comments
-
S. Krupkowski
commented
This is still a problem. [InDesign 16.2.1/Windows 10 Enterprise].
I submitted a new bug report, but was unable to attach the INDD file. Error message stated "File type for [filename.indd] not supported." Didn't matter if I dragged file, or clicked to upload.A screen shot is attached here instead.
See attached screen shot.
-
Lora
commented
Updated to Indesign 16.1, 2021. Still had to change the left indent to have the type with the appropriately gap, but now it recognizes the bullets so they wrap as well. Thank you
-
Lukas Engqvist commented
Having ability to insert emspace followed by ”indent to here” would be an alternative, or compliment.
-
Anonymous
commented
Noooo. This was fixed last year and now it's broken again.
Using Adobe InDesign 2021 (16.0.1)
macOS Catalina 10.15.7 -
Ian Davies
commented
This has broken again with the 15.0.2 update. Correct behaviour 2 weeks ago, now open the same document this week and if you move a text-wrapped object, the indent gets applied twice on subsequent lines.
**EDIT** Helpfully(!), the images get displayed in the reverse order they were added, so the first image is the incorrect behaviour with double indent, and the second image is the original, correct behaviour.
-
Kim
commented
I'm having this same issue with numbered lists. I'm making edits to an existing document. I've updated my InDesign since the last time I worked on it, and now anywhere that I have icons in numbered lists, the alignment has gone whacky (it doubles the left indent for every line after the first line that wraps around the icon). Is this a bug fix that is coming any time soon?
-
Lora
commented
On my machine it looks like it's completely ignoring the text wrap. I'm on a Mac OS Mojave fully loaded. This is a major problem for us as we use nothing but bulleted type.
-
jamaica
commented
HELP! The Bulleted lists feature does not work regardless of text wrapping or not. Cannot be corrected via tabs or paragraph palette. Instead, bulleted lists need to be created manually via hanging indents and the good old bullet symbol. OR, saved back and built in 2019.
-
CS5 omachi
commented
This is not Fixed!
Text indent has been changed to be relative to the text wrap boundary, but the tab origin remains the frame inset. In this state, it works as expected for indented lines, but it does not work as expected for bulleted or autonumbered lines.
To completely fix it, the starting point of the tab position must be the boundary of the text wrap. -
Paul Nylander
commented
Just stumbled across this problem myself—apparently Adobe hasn't addressed it yet, as I'm running the 14.0.2 version of InDesign, and still see it. It becomes especially apparent when only some of the bulleted lines are affected—in this case, the red box has a text wrap around it, and although it doesn't actually touch any of the text (in other words, it isn't even doing anything) the two last items in the list are kicked to the left just a bit. A real problem.
-
Jamie Nisbet
commented
I am also having this problem!
-
Anonymous
commented
Text wrap is using the scaling of an image to also scale the hard number keyed in. For example, and image scaled to 75% with a text wrap of .25" will wrap the text at .1875".
-
Zach
commented
This is a major issue in InDesign. I cannot rely on bulleted lists to behave properly and often have to manually setup bulleted lists.
-
Tobias Wantzen
commented
Thanks, that’s great to hear!
Tobias -
Tobias Wantzen
commented
Thank’s Payal – you can download the video from my server:
http://www.wantzen.com/TextWrapKillsIndents.movThe image box in the left is set to »wrap bounding box«.
-
Payal Awasthi
commented
Hi,
Can you please just add a small demo video (on WeTransfer/Youtube/Dropbox) and share the link, so that we can properly understand the problem you are facing.
You can also send the link directly to paawasth@adobe.com
-Payal (InDesign Team)
-
Tobias Wantzen
commented
I'm wondering, if this is a feature request or a bug report ...?! Anyway.
