[ID-4257733]The amount of “Indent to Here” in a paragraph with a “Text Wrap” object at the beginning of the line is wider than usual.
- Version of Adobe InDesign Windows CC2023-2024
- Steps to reproduce the issues Place an object with "Text Wrap" at the beginning of the line and insert "Indent to Here" in the paragraph.
- Expected result Wrap at "Indent to Here"
- Actual result A gap is created where the "Text Wrap" is added to the wrap of "Indent to Here".
I suspect that the issue mentioned in the post below may be related to it being fixed in 2023 (18.0).
https://indesign.uservoice.com/forums/601180-adobe-indesign-bugs/suggestions/42200695-text-wrapping-has-changed-to-before-2019-use-textf
It was working normally until CC2022, but problems have been occurring since CC2023.
Explanation of the attached image
"Paragraph 1.: Indent to Here"
"Paragraph 2.: Normal Indent"
Indent results for each version
It seems that the following also has a similar problem.
https://indesign.uservoice.com/forums/601180-adobe-indesign-bugs/suggestions/46883353-problem-with-honor-text-indents-in-addition-to-t
─────────────────────────────
行頭に「テキストの回り込み」オブジェクトのある段落の「ここまでインデント」の空き量が通常より広い
- InDesignのバージョン Windows版CC2023-2024
- 問題を再現する手順 行頭に「テキストの回り込み」のオブジェクトを置き、段落内に「ここまでインデント」を入れる
- 期待される結果 「ここまでインデント」での折り返し
- 実結果 「ここまでインデント」の折り返しに「テキストの回り込み」分が加算された広い空きができる
下記の投稿にある問題が2023（18.0）で修正されたことが関係しているのではないかと疑っています。
https://indesign.uservoice.com/forums/601180-adobe-indesign-bugs/suggestions/42200695-text-wrapping-has-changed-to-before-2019-use-textf
「ここまでインデント」に関してはCC2022までは正常な動作をしていましたがCC2023から問題が発生しています
添付画像の説明
バージョンごとのインデントの結果
「1.の段落：ここまでインデント」
「2.の段落：通常のインデント」
下記も同様の問題の投稿のようです
https://indesign.uservoice.com/forums/601180-adobe-indesign-bugs/suggestions/46883353-problem-with-honor-text-indents-in-addition-to-t
tacomakix
shared this idea
AdminSanyam Talwar
(Senior Lead Software Engineer, Adobe InDesign)
responded
The fix for this issue is available in the InDesign PreRelease build(v20.2.0.024) and above.
Please check if the issue is now resolved.
Download/Update the latest InDesign PreRelease build in Creative Cloud under the “Prerelease” category(Refer to “Prerelease_CreativeCloud.png” for reference)
Please apply to the InDesign PreRelease in case you don’t have access to the InDesign PreRelease build – https://www.adobeprerelease.com/beta/C6DFA254-C40C-4EEB-8F6D-F4AEDA2E6171
If you still encounter any issues, please drop a mail to sharewithID@adobe.com.
—
Adobe InDesign team
-
monokano
commented
InDesign 2025 (Prerelease) (20.2.0.24)
I have confirmed that this bug has been fixed. Thank you. -
monokano
commented
Do you need an example of how to use the ‘Indent to Here’ feature? Should I explain this basic InDesign feature to you? Discussing the use of this feature is unnecessary. The real issue is the serious bug that's clearly present.
--
「ここまでインデント」機能の使い方についての例が必要ですか？ この基本的なInDesignの機能を説明する必要がありますか？ この機能の使い方について議論するのは不要です。問題は、明らかに重大なバグがあることです。 -
tacomakix
commented
The “Bulleted List” feature is not in use. This is reporting that the behavior of the indent is strange when using “Indent to Here”.
「箇条書きリスト」機能は使用していません。これは「ここまでインデント」を使用した時にインデントの挙動がおかしいことを報告しています。
-
monokano
commented
Video of Abnormal ‘Indent to Here’ Behavior
(The video was re-recorded to avoid unnecessary and extraneous discussion.)
https://mega.nz/file/Ut4xVagT#dq8aMFCWjr-V3FdnCLiMpcTf7Z95T1oIVTNrqeStQ8Y -
monokano
commented
This is a bug that occurs when the feature "Honor Text Indents in addition to Text Wrap" that was added in 2023 (v18) is turned ON.
----
これは2023（v18）で追加された機能「テキストの回り込み時にテキストのインデントを維持」をONにすると発生するバグです。 -
Dimitris Mandelias commented
InDesign version 18.2.1, I searched but couldn't find the same issue anywhere else, so I report it here. Attached is a PDF file with the problem. Description is as follows.
There are 3 paragraphs of text, the middle one in black color to be clear. "Honor Text Indents in addition to Text Wrap" is ON.
Needless to say that NO yellow frame has any runaround applied to it. They are there for illustrative purposes.
On the second (black text) paragraph, everything is just OK. The paragraph has a 20 mm left indent and the runaround of the red frame is 30 mm. All is working as it should.
But, on the 3rd paragraph, immediately before the bold-red-all_caps text in the first line, I have inserted and "indent-to-here" character, to which indent 30mm more of space is added due to the runaround of the frame and the option "Honor Text Indents in addition to Text Wrap" turned ON. The lower part of the same paragraph (just after the yellow frame with 30mm in it) is correctly indented to the "indent-to-here" character, something that SHOULD have occured to the whole paragraph.
Thank you very much for reading,
Dimitris