How can we improve InDesign?

Make InDesign be able to import/Export comments from/to PDF

I want to be able to get the comments from PDF into InDesign so that I can easily incorporate/respond on the comments from people.

88 votes
Sign in
Check!
(thinking…)
Reset
or sign in with
  • facebook
  • google
    Password icon
    Signed in as (Sign out)

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    Jesper shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →

    65 comments

    Sign in
    Check!
    (thinking…)
    Reset
    or sign in with
    • facebook
    • google
      Password icon
      Signed in as (Sign out)
      Submitting...
      • Kelly Vaughn commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        @Laura: What is your version of InDesign? Sometimes the CC app says you're updated, but you might still be at an earlier version if you're running an older operating system. This feature was rolled out in version 14.0.

        What version OS are you running?

        Once you are at version 14.0, it should be just another panel, available under Window > PDF Comments.

        Yes, PDFs that were made from a previous version of InDesign cannot have their comments imported into the PDF Comments panel in InDesign. A workaround is to export the comments from the older PDF to a data file, make a new PDF in the new version of InDesign, transfer the comments into it (in Acrobat, export comments to data file. Then you can import the comments into InDesign.

        Also, as this feature does not allow you to select a page range, it will not work with books. Because you have no way to select a page range of the PDF when you import it. I suppose if you really needed to, you could manually break apart your PDF and save out a bunch of different files which you could then import into InDesign.

        this feature is still version 1.0. If you're looking for something that's got more features, I'd look into DTP Tools Annotations. It's been around for over five years and works very well. http://www.dtptools.com/product.asp?id=anid

      • Laura Sutherland commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        I'm trying to test this at home before we roll it out at work — according to the Cloud, I've upgraded to the latest InD CC version, but there is no "Import PDF Comments" menu item, nor is there a "PDF comments" window. Do I need to activate it in some way or is it not available because we use templates originally created in (much) earlier versions of InD (but updated through the years)? And is it correct that PDF comments already marked from previous versions of InD can't be imported? Thanks.

      • Heather Christian commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        I'm excited about this new feature, but it's a bit disappointing that it doesn't work for PDFs exported from the book panel. As a book designer who works exclusively out of the book panel and goes through multiple rounds of revisions with authors via PDF, this is a huge drawback. Any plans to have that option available in a future update?

      • Rainer Klute commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        To be honest: it does not work properly, it is still kind of beta and no one should rely on this. :-(

      • Raphaël Freeman commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        How about getting it to work with the Adobe World Composer reliably? Or is that just another ME bug that we will have to live with for the next 20 years?

      • Steve Edwards commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        In using this in the final release of 2019, there are a couple of things I've spotted that could be improved:

        1) The sticky notes icons are VERY large compared to how they look in Acrobat. It's quite difficult to see where the note is actually referring to, especially when working on a document with a lot of comments.

        2) The sticky note icons cannot be moved (only removed by either ticking the Resolved checkbox or by deleting the comment) so it's hard to read the text underneath. When going through comments in the PDF, I would normally move the note I'm working on so I can see what the text used to be and can then make a call on what the change actually is. Our customers aren't always too precise with the changes and it needs a bit of thought!

        In response to the comments (from me as well!) about only being able to use comments from a PDF created in 2019, you can export the comments from the comments panel in Acrobat then reimport them into your PDF created in 2019 and it will then open into InDesign!

      • Matt Mayerchak commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        NOTES from first trial:

        1) Why does the PDF have to be created from InDesign CC2019? I can't understand the technical reason for this and it's a HUGE drawback.

        2) I did several markups over 3 pages of a 50+ page PDF. The ones that imported worked well - a few striketrhoughs and a few text replacments.

        3) Several of the edits did not work - it said they could not be mapped. Why not? No rhyme or reason to which ones failed. If they are basic text edits done with the commenting tools, they had better ALL work or it's worthless. Editors will not accept 75% of edits being OK and the other 25% being lost. Adobe really needs to figure out why some don't work.

        4) Annotations plugin from DTP tools adds a highlight to show where an edit has been made. (Jan put this in at my suggestion). It's extremely helpful because I can accept all edits for a whole page at a time, then go check them. Often the editor includes an extra word space, or removes a word space, or misses one charactrer or punctuation mark when striking out text.

        5) I would STRONGLY encourage the Adobe team to use the Annotations plugin and see how it works, and emulate as much as they can about it (except the import annotations dialog, which is substandard and wonky). But, here are some features they should copy:

        a) having indicators in the InDesign showing all the annotations locations BEFORE you accept them (because sometimes they come in wrong, which usually means you edited the InDesign file since the PDF was made);

        b) highlighting the edits after they have been made until you choose to remove those;

        c) the small comment dialog that shows the text of a comment, whether it's a text edit or a design comment - with these, at least we can still copy the text from a comment even when it was done as a sticky note, rather than having to copy it from Acrobat.

        d) the ability to choose which page to start on - because you know some people omit pages from PDFs, or send partial pdfs to editors

        e) the ability to work on a PDF saved as spreads. I know this is not how it should be done; but many designers give spread pdfs to clients because the clients are not smart enough to view the pdf as spreads in Acrobat, or print them out as spreads, so they are dummy-proofing their output. I tell designers that if they do this, make sure to give them a single-pages pdf for editing, but you cannot control the editors and they will edit the spreads pdf if it exists. With Annotations, this is not technically supposed to work, but it does!

        I fully expect that, as they did with Endnotes, Adobe will include a half-baked version of this in the next release and it will make the whole process horrible for all who use it. Right now we have enough trouble getting people to understand the difference between using comments to annotate a PDF and editing the PDF directly. I have seen several projects where an editor spent many hours directly editing a PDF and then sent that to us to import. A complete waste of time but they simply do what seems obvious to them before asking anybody and Adobe makes it "intuitive" so there is no reason to think this is not a good idea. It would be nice if Adobe spent 5 minutes thinking about human nature and how people in the real world use their products before adding or removing tools, but as we have seen in many instances, such as the addition of the [+] overrides toggle that automatically adds blue highlighting and has freaked out many a designer, they spent very little time trying to understand their users. So, I have ZERO confidence that this feature will be worth using until at least 4 updates, if ever.

        p.s. still waiting for live endnotes that work; until then I have to keep CC2017 running so I can import Word files that have footnotes and then bring them into CC2018. I know there is a script for that but it's easier to just import them correctly.

      • Steve Edwards commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        I noticed in the beta that it only works on PDFs made from that version of InDesign and then comments added. I tried on an old actual job with the comments on and it wouldn't import. Is that how the final functionality will work? I ask because we do get some customers who update old PDFs (which we still have current InDesign files for) and it would be good to use this new function on those jobs in the future if possible.

      • Rich Coda commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        For me, for this to work, it would HAVE to be able to work from the back to the front. My clients, OK, OK... ONE particular client ALWAYS makes layout busting changes. I work with a single threaded text box as much as possible... working on a 48 page job right now. She ads just one small word, sometimes even just a character, or breaks a paragraph into two, and it screws EVERYTHING after that. Even after 15 years with this client, I try to explain to her that text is like a river... throw a pebble into it upstream and it will ripple downstream. And, of course, she constantly moves things (graphics) to different pages, which of course, 100% of the time messes everything up. So, I learned a long time ago (even before annotations in Acrobat were functional, even before Acrobat... like in "faxed in changes") to work with her files from the back. Do all the text changes first so we are "on the same page" so to speak, and then deal with the layout busters.

      • Raphaël Freeman commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Three requests:
        1. Please make sure it works when optical margin alignment is on.
        2. Please make sure it works with the Adobe World Composer.
        3. Please make sure it can handle large documents (most of my work is on documents that are between 200–600 pages of text often with many pictures and Annotations is very slow with large documents)

        I currently use Annotations which has saved me literally 1000s of hours of work but it doesn’t work with the World Composer and has errors when corrections are made to hanging punctuation at the end of a line.

        I would be willing to beta test this since I spend several hours every day on corrections.

      • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Hi Abhinav,
        I would like to ask how it looks? When we can expect function - Import comments PDF to Indesign?

        Thanks

      • Georg Stadler commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        I just read through the proposed specs. Looking great.
        I have a question though: Is there a way to approve or decline annotations. What I mean by this is, will I be able to just click a button to accept a proposed change and the change will be reflected in the ID-Document.
        Like in InCopy.
        Furthermore, what will happen if a change results in massive shift of text (i.e. inserting a paragraph in a book) will the other changes keep up with the new flow of text?

      • Lindsey Thomas Martin commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Abhinav, I think option 4 would generally work best. Option 2 might work as well; options 1 and 3 are not desirable. It is important to see the mark-up in situ. You might consider modifying option 4 or 2 so the mark-up fades a bit when the user begins to edit so one can see it is there but there will less danger of the point of editing being obscured.

        This probably conflicts with the annotation coming into focus when overlapped by the cursor. I find Acrobat's method of bringing annotations into focus not easy to see. Fading might be a good alternative, though perhaps counterintuitive.

      • TM commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        The proposed workflow looks great. I agree with Raja, hiding / showing the comments using scripting should be possible. This is very Important. Any suggestions on adding annotations and comments in Indesign ?

      • Raja, Gejaraj commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Thanks Abhinav, I prefer option #4, as users will ensure that all the comments are properly imported by cross-verifying the comments and hope we'll have an option thro' Scripting to block the PDF generation process when the user is forgetting to hide the comments and retaining in the layout.

        Also please confirm whether users will have an option to show again the comments after hiding the comments?

      • AdminAbhinav Agarwal (Product Manager, Adobe InDesign) commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Quick question:

        As you can see in specs, there is an option to show all the comments on the Id layout. For example, text will be highlighted if reviewer had used the highlight tool. Similarly, for a drawing tool, corresponding drawing would be shown on layout.

        Consider the scenario: comments are shown on layout and user wants to edit the document. What is the
        expectation in this scenario?

        1) As soon as user starts to edit the document, all the comments hide automatically from layout (they will still be seen in the panel)
        2) As soon as user selects a page item, all the comments attached to that page items hide automatically. All other comments on the layout will remain visible
        3) Editing of document gets blocked until the time user hides all the comment on the layout
        4) All comments remain visible on layout while user is editing the document. User can hide comments manually if need be.

        Which option you prefer and why? We want to ensure that editing is not obstructed in any way.

      • AdminAbhinav Agarwal (Product Manager, Adobe InDesign) commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Thanks Lindsey and Raja for your comments.

        Answers to your queries:
        1) Regarding unidentified comments: these will be comments which InDesign can't map properly if Id document had been modified before importing the comments. If document was not modified, all comments would map properly

        2) All imported comments will persist with the Id document. However, these comments will not be exported if Id document is exported as PDF

        3) Maintaining history of review round is not possible.

        4) XML functionality is not impacted with this feature. It will continue to work as before

      ← Previous 1 3 4

      Feedback and Knowledge Base