[ID-4208669]QR-Code Generator Problems with Umlauts in vCards
In the actual version of indesign (16.0) there is still an issue with internal generated vCard-QR-Code scanned by an iphone.
In germany there are special Characters called "Umlaute" (ü, ö, ä) or the "sharp s" (ß). If these characters are used in an vCard generated within the buildin function from indesign, they are replaced with other symbols on the iPhone QR-Code-Camera Reader.
I think this is only a Problem of the used vCard-Version. I think indesign uses Version 2.1 if you would just use Version 3.0 this issue does not appear.
please see attached one example
Kind regards from germany
Max
Thanks for reporting. We will review the issue shortly
-InDesign Team
-
Corinne Catelain commented
I still find it strong, that in 2022, character encoding is still a problem. There are many languages with accents.
I make hundreds of business cards a year, I have just integrated the QR code and it looks completely digital, it's a shame to be blocked by a "small detail" of encoding
-
Max Behnen commented
In the actual version of indesign (18.0) there is still an issue with internal generated vCard-QR-Code scanned by an iphone. I filed this bugs also two years ago
In germany there are special Characters called "Umlaute" (ü, ö, ä) or the "sharp s" (ß). If these characters are used in an vCard generated within the buildin function from indesign, they are replaced with other symbols on the iPhone QR-Code-Camera Reader.
I think this is only a Problem of the used vCard-Version. I think indesign uses Version 2.1 if you would just use Version 3.0 this issue does not appear.
please see attached one example
Kind regards from germany
Max
-
Max Behnen commented
@amaarora The bug is still not fixed in Indesign 2023 Version 18.0
-
Michael commented
I have the same problem with "ü" and "ß". We need a bugfix, otherwise its not usable in germany, switzerland, austria, poland etc.
-
Margit Jõerand commented
Please fix this!
-
gestyle commented
2022 : Professional Software requires professional features and options. QR-Codes-management (formats-selection, accentuated characters handling, etc..) should be available. Bugfree for deployment. :)
It’s a critical issue for all content creators / agencies.
What can we do to help ADOBE fix it asap ?
-
Geoff commented
France, many names and (most) addresses have accented characters.
It's an insult to not spell a person's name correctly.
Clément
Gaëlle
Gérard -
Sertaç Ögüt commented
Shocked to see that this is still an issue.
-
Christophe Huget commented
Hello, I discover this issue today (May 5th, 2022) working on QR code VCards I'm currently working on using latest version of Indesign available (V17.2.1). I read amaarora saying this issue will be reviewed by InDesign Team shortly after November 4th, 2020 (more than one year and a half). AMAARORA Do you have any news today?
-
Orsolya Kassai commented
Please fix it, thank you
-
Alfred commented
No way to make QR, please!!!!!! From v.14
-
Robert B. commented
When will this issue be resolved?
Polish chars ie., ą, ę, ł., ó. -
Wojciech Puza commented
The same problem with polish letters: ĄąĆćĘꣳŃńÓ󌜯żŹź (only 18 characters). Iphone don't recognise them.
Maybe you should open a Support Ticket at Apple? -
Marcus Brunström commented
This is actually quite terrible. To not UTF encode is a disaster! Fix it!
-
Max Behnen commented
Yes please the new version 17.0 still has this bug
-
Ralf commented
Hi, is there any progress because of this problem? it was posted over a year ago.
Kind regards
-
Vilhelm von Platen commented
I found a workaround to this, using data merge.
When you create the source data for data merge like in https://www.tech4pub.com/2015/02/03/indesign-cc-tip-adding-qr-codes-with-data-merge/, you can specify vcard version 3.0 instead of 2.1 and then the issues goes away. Terribly annoying if you only need to make one or a couple of codes, but it works.I used the concatenation function in excel to generate the vcard data from existing cells of data. Also terribly annoying.
This function from adobe "works" but is not really usable. Really makes you wonder what they do with our money.
-
Iben Busch commented
That was November 2020.... September 2021 - It is still not fixed..
-
as commented
same problem still there...
thanks for updating vcard to 3.0 in indesign very very soon. -
mru commented
same hereI fix it immediately, please!