[ID-4216880]Placed graphic displays and exports outside stroke.
A placed graphic will show onscreen and in graphic exports like PNG and JPG outside the stroke when the stroke is aligned to the inside of the frame. InDesign 2020 and earlier. To reproduce: place a graphic, add a stroke to the frame, align stroke to inside, export the page to jpg or png. A thin portion of the image is visible outside the stroke. Obviously, this is most noticeable when the stroke is thick and white.
Mike Rankin
shared this idea
Thank you for reporting the issue to us.
We are currently reviewing it.
InDesign Team
-
Gary Anderson commented
I've noticed this problem for sooooo many years, it's seriously irritating and unnecessary. Come on Adobe, get it sorted please. This isn't Quark Xpress you know.
-
Colin
commented
I'm experiencing this too.
-
A placed graphic will show onscreen and in graphic exports like PNG and JPG outside the stroke when the stroke is aligned to the inside of the frame. InDesign 2020 and earlier. To reproduce: place a graphic, add a stroke to the frame, align stroke to inside, export the page to jpg or png. A thin portion of the image is visible outside the stroke. Obviously, this is most noticeable when the stroke is thick and white.
-
Georgina
commented
I've been selecting objects and exporting them as 72 / 96ppi jpegs. Whenever I inspect these files, there's a small white border added to the top and bottom. It's bizarre and i'm at a loss for why this would happen.
-
Uwe Laubender
commented
Hi Dimitij,
a longstanding bug, I think.
Already saw this with e.g. InDesign CS5.The issue is the alignment of the stroke: Inside Path
Also test different types of images. JPEG, TIFF, PSD and ( just for testing, but not for production: ) EPS saved from PhotoShop.
I can recall that in one occassion EPS was superior to TIFF or JPEG, but nowadays with color management in mind no one will or should use the EPS file format over a TIFF, JPEG or a PSD file format where ICC profiles could be applied.Regards,
Uwe Laubender
( ACP ) -
Dmitrij
commented
Buggy thin line (part of the photo inside frame) is visible If frame have stroke aligned inside of the frame. See the screenshot and photo of issue. Photo present proof from printed after RIP in printing house.
Problem is known from 2009 and still exist!