How can we improve InDesign?

No repeat option wanted for headers and footers in table options

When you've got headers and footers in tables, there is no way to prevent them from repeating at all.

There are currently three options in InDesign Table Options:
1. Every Text Column
2. Once per Frame
3. Once per Page

I'd like to see an option for "NONE" or "NO REPEAT".

I can also think of "Once per Spread" as a valid setting, but NONE is the most important, since the current solution is to convert the headers to body rows, and that destroys the information about the header rows actually being headers.

11 votes
Sign in
(thinking…)
Sign in with: facebook google
Signed in as (Sign out)

We’ll send you updates on this idea

Andreas shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →

3 comments

Sign in
(thinking…)
Sign in with: facebook google
Signed in as (Sign out)
Submitting...
  • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I would like the ability to mark a body row as a header row (or a similar solution) so that alternating fills ignores these rows.

  • Andreas commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hi Roy,

    Think of Table styles and working with hundreds of tables in your documents... and then the sudden need to change those table into showing no repeated headers (and then back into repeated headers again).

    Using Table styles, header rows can not be styled differently from body rows, unless they ARE marked as headers.

    If you've only got one table in your document, the problem is not a big one. The thing is that you can not change this behaviour and apply (or keep) such a special formatting for header rows, that you mention, on many tables at once.

    Example: Last year I imported xml (with head AND cell data marked up separately), creating 100s of tables in a document with headers repeated for each column. I used a table style to set up separate formats for headers and body cells. When almost all the manual touch-up was done in the document our customer decides that the headers are not to be repeated. Since InDesign lacks the ability to change this in a simple way we had either to change all this manually (converting row by row) or via scripting, calling "Convert to Body" and explicitly setting individual Cell styles for the top-most cells.
    The number of header rows may also be more than one for each table: It's no a good idea to recognize a type of data (header contents) just by its formatting attributes. If you want to do something with all header rows, you can't just make a script that affects all "first rows" of all tables, you need to check some part of a style attribute.

    So yes, we want them to be header rows, not to lose their status as headers, in case we'd like to change their behaviour back into repeating headers or change their formats.

  • Roy Behymer commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Is there a reason it has to be a header, yet not behave as a header by repeating at the head of frames/pages/etc.? If it's only to be on the first page, there's no reason I know to have InDesign treat it as a header. It sounds like it is a body row, just with special formatting to distinguish it from the actual table body.
    Am I missing something?

Feedback and Knowledge Base