Igor
My feedback
7 results found
-
4 votesIgor
supported this idea
·
An error occurred while saving the comment -
230 votes
Password protection of Publish Online documents is available, starting with InDesign 19.4 version.
--
Adobe InDesign team
An error occurred while saving the comment Igor
commented
According to Azhar Hussain from Adobe, this is a HIGH PRIORITY on their roadmap. Since nothing has been done, announced, communicated or changed since September 2023, I can only fear what happens if it is NOT a high priority..
An error occurred while saving the comment Igor
commented
UPDATE:
Apparently, Abhinav Kaushik doesn't work at Adobe anymore and hasn't for some time. That's probably the reason this critical request has been forgotten about. I have raised one ticket after another to get this ball rolling again, and with a LOT of patience, time and effort I got to one of the new developers of this piece of software Azhar Hussain. I will copy and paste the mail he sent me below. In short: don't get your hopes up - Adobe is not inclined to listen and even less to actually do something worthwhile for their clients who have been (not so) patient for more than 5 years... they're delaying hoping we will forget. Truth be said: we will. We'll just switch to other software. I believe they're waiting to cancel the whole interactive publishing - I can see no other reason for Adobe dragging their feet with this. Not if they are serious about listening to us.
Here's the email:
-------------------------------------
Hi Igor,
I sincerely apologize for the delay in getting back to you here.
With regards to the problem that you’ve highlighted, I appreciate all the details that you have shared as well as the engagement on the UV threads. I would like to assure you that this concern is a high priority item on our roadmap and we are most assuredly listening to the community feedback.
We’ve actively evaluated both the proposed solutions – i) Password Protection and ii) Support for 3rd party hosting but
unfortunately, in light of other features and product enhancements which were more critical, and the effort required to do justice to this feature, we were not able to pick up this feature for 2023 planning.Would the capability to export out the Publish Online document as a HTML5 package that maybe hosted anywhere, solve your concerns in terms of privacy and security?
While I would not be able to provide an ETA for when this feature would be available, I am confident that we would be able to pick this up as part of our 2024 roadmap.
As you may appreciate, these solutions are complicated in nature and require careful consideration before we ship these out for our customers.
If you have any further questions or if there's anything you would like to discuss, I will be happy to setup some common time for us.Thank you
Azhar Hussain
------------------------------An error occurred while saving the comment Igor
commented
This feature request has been here since 2017! It has been voted into the top for a LONG time, but nothing NOTHING is being done... Still, just up for review since 2020... The problem is still there! this makes me incredibly angry, unheard, unseen, and it feels like Adobe doesn't take its customers seriously. IT'S BEEN HERE 6 YEARS!!!!!
ADOBE! START LISTENING TO YOUR CUSTOMERS!!!!!!!!
An error occurred while saving the comment Igor
commented
My client has ordered me to take down ALL the interactive documents published on the CC servers since it is not within their security influence, and forbidden to use them ever again. Security- and privacy issues are a growing concern. There is no way to password-protect the interactive documents or allow only access through their own proxy servers... so then we need a way for them to host the documents themselves on their Sharepoint intranet or other secure servers. Interactive pdf (or what's left of it) is as dead as a doornail, so that is no alternative; export as epub requires a reader and doesn't work in browsers... In conclusion: if this feature is not implemented quickly, they (and us, sadly too) will be forced to turn our backs on Adobe as a partner.
That would be a shame
Igor
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesIgor
supported this idea
·
-
8 votesIgor
supported this idea
·
-
17 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Igor
commented
It's silly it isn't there yet... After all these years!
Igor
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesIgor
supported this idea
·
-
5 votesIgor
supported this idea
·
yes.. I ran into the issue too!